Question:
What laptop is right for me? Should I get a Mac?
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
What laptop is right for me? Should I get a Mac?
Six answers:
M
2007-04-20 20:41:49 UTC
PC or Mac...you'll have to buy Word either way.

I started my computer experience on Macs back in 1988. I got tired of the high-cost/inflexibility/lack of software and cut over to a PC in 1994. I loved the PC. I could build what I wanted, find the software I wanted, was cheap to upgrade/rebuild/replace. I became a reformed Mac user. I wouldn't even consider looking at one. Until last month.

My son is going into middle school and I have enrolled in a laptop-based curriculum. The laptop requirement is a Mac. I rolled my eyes and went to the store get my wallet rolled too. I wasn't in that Apple store more than 15 minutes and I was ready to buy one not only for my son, but for myself! The MacOS operating system is WAY cool. I was frustrated with the hacky, kludgy method of importing video in the PC. When I brought home the Mac, I had video off my camera, and on the PC, edited within an hour. You just plain plug it in and it works. Now I know I'm giving up an easy upgrade path, but for typical usage, the Mac is great. For graphical creativity, it can't be beat. My aunt used to publish a dog breeder magazine and used the Mac exclusively. I'm not giving up the PC, I'm just going to be adding the Mac.

Some tips when buying:

I also didn't really want to pay for the Mac-premium. But you can (as I did) save some bucks.

First, there is the bargain-basement way: craigslist. Just make sure you run it through a session as if you were going to use it yourself to make sure it works. Meet at a hot zone to ensure the wireless works. Burn a CD, etc.

If you would rather buy new, ask the Apple store if they have any 'Refreshed' units. I accidentally discovered a stack of these under a table. I ended up upgrading the laptop to a black/1G/80G/SuperDrive unit for almost the same price as the lowest model Mac. I saved $200 on a machine that was factory-inspected returned unit. Same warranty as new, undamaged, everything included. Probably the best route to take.

I also bought the AppleCare, which extends your warranty out to 3 years. A bit spendy at $250, BUT if you know someone who is an educator, you can pick up the AppleCare for about $180.

I will be buying MS Office, and the best price I found was at Amazon.com, Student edition for $130, free shipping, no sales tax. $150 in the store + 8.75% where I live.

Yes you can get a cheap Dell, but as a student, using Word, photos and coolness...spend the extra for the Mac. I spend a lot of time on my PCs making sure I'm not hackable, virus-free, fixing bugs...fortunately I see a lot that as a challenge, but to have something that will always work and is not a real virus target...I think my next machine will be a Mac.

so there you have it! Did I answer your question..probably not. In the end only you can make that decision. We can only point out the advantages and disadvantages to either.

Good luck!

Also...since Macs are now Intel-based, in the future you can upgrade yourself to an application that emulates Windows. You can have both on one machine.

You are getting a lot of good info from the other answers I see posted too. Play with both. You won't be disappointed either way. Lastly, try to get sucked into the Mac vs. PC, Ford vs. Chevy, Coke Vs. Pepsi, 9mm vs. .45 mentality. It's all good!
jayztttight
2007-04-20 20:39:09 UTC
Your not going to get a really good Mac for 1000 dollars. Mac's are nice, but they are not cheap, they have had battery issues, and a Windows PC is geared more towards productivity (despite what a Mac user would tell you).



Try not to get Windows Vista. Trust me I have Windows Vista, and I am still using XP. It just doesn't work as reliably as Xp right now. You could get Vista though if you don't really care about a bug or 2 there, or if you don't have a lot of favorite programs you use.



So....... I'm going to throw some specs at you. Just stick to this guideline when looking for a laptop.



At least 4-5 hours of power running off the battery.



Windows XP Home or Professional ( I don't see why you would need Pro though(unless you want to use IIS as your server, but you should use apache).



1-2 GB of DDR2 Ram (More = faster & you can have more programs open @ same time)



Dual Core CPU (Just means a faster computer. Try to stick with Intel, at least for laptops. You could go Core 2 Duo but thst is more expensive, so whatever you want).



80-120 GB Hard drive (that holds a lot of music & images. If you want to hold more, you can get an external hard drive)



Built in Wifi, 802.11 a/b/g (this is internet capable, wireless capable)



15.4 inch screen (will mean smaller base, meaning less weight)



Get it with Microsoft Office (or order it separately online, wherever. You can either get Office 2003 or 2007. On a side note, I REALLY, REALLY like Microsoft OneNote 2007. If you use it for like a week, you will wonder what you did without it. Easily my favorite app in whole Office Suite. Try to see if you can grab it).



I see the laptop I just explained to you to be like 1000-1400. You might want to add extra options.



I currently have the HP dv 6000t.



It's one of the nicest laptops (currently the most popular on cnet.com, on a side note I actually wrote a review for that laptop and it is the best ranked user review http://reviews.cnet.com/HP_Pavilion_dv6000t_Core_2_Duo/4505-3121_7-32036702.html?tag=prod.txt.2 I really give an indepth review. My name is blazin_it_alwyz, and the review is called Cnet's review is so bias. I'm basically criticizing Cnet for their review, but I digress.



I love my computer. I paid 1800 for it, but I got an extra battery (subtract 100), I have 2 year warranty (subtract another 100)

and other stuff you don't need, and I have one of the best laptop setups. Read my review, go to notebookreview.com, do some research, use the tips I gave you, and good luck.
Linds
2007-04-20 20:29:12 UTC
You can get a windows model for a whole lote less, with plently of memory. Check these out.





Compaq 799.99

100 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8294428&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1172880155827



Gateway 849.99

100 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8224762&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1166840116855



Gateway 849.99

160 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8309984&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1173578008196



Gateway 799.99

100 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8242449&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1168044604173



Gateway 649.99

160 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8310008&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1173577987807



HP 949.99

120 GB Hard Drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8310008&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1173577987807



HP 849.99

120 GB hard drive

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8310008&type=product&productCategoryId=pcmcat103700050047&id=1173577987807
2007-04-20 20:27:56 UTC
yes, pfft a mac, who in thei right mindwould buy a mac. lol. yer as jacob said ring up dell tell them what you want and see how much it costs. dells are always the cheapest not because tey cut on quality but because they have minimal workshops, thy dont make you computer until you order it, so they dont have to worry about surplus stock.
jacob c
2007-04-20 20:23:22 UTC
sorry to say you want flexible and cheep thats not mac. a mac pc is what your going to want if you want cheep and flexible. go with a cheep dell or hp or some thing like that. then think do you want to spened the money on repairs to a mac are not cheep at all. given they are great for creating graphics and music. but for word processing and managing websites get a pc that what they where made fore.
rickrudge
2007-04-20 21:17:56 UTC
Hi Katie B,



I'm definitely into the Macintosh. I think that it's the best out there, and you really get your money's worth. Getting one for only a 1,000 bucks is kind of tough, but not impossible. For simple word processing and a little Internet, you don't need the cutting edge versions of Macs. Have you considered getting a refurbished or a used Macintosh? PowerMax has a bunch for you. Check them out here:



http://www.powermax.com/



Their refurbished Macs keep their warranty, so they're a good deal. OK here's my list of things I like about the Macintosh over Windows. I'm sorry that it is so long, but that's how it goes.



* No computer viruses.

You hear from the Windows people that it's because there are fewer Macs out there, but I think it's because of the Mac OS and it's Unix kernel. That doesn't explain why Vista got viruses before it was officially released. The Macintosh comes out of the box as a closed system. If you want it to be networked and remotely operated, you can make that happen, but you have to change it's settings first. Windows machines come out of the box as a wide open vulnerable system. That's so the IT guy can set up the hardware, attach it to the company's network, and install the software remotely from the comfort of his own desk. ActiveX and InternetExplorer leaves the Windows OS wide open to hacks and viruses. The Macintosh OS simply isn't set up that way.



If you want to install any kind of software onto your Mac, you first need to type in your administrative password. There is no auto-install for a virus to attach itself to your Mac without your Okay. That is the simple answer why there hasn't been any viruses for the Macintosh in the past 6 years. Another is that first year programmers learn how to create simple Windows script viruses their first year of class. Mac programmers simply love their computers and have no desire to create such an abomination. We love our Mac programmers and happily pay what ever they ask for their good, hard work.



* Games.

I enjoy the games that I play on my Mac, but It's true that there simply aren't as many games out there for the Mac as Windows. Hopefully, with the Mac now using an Intel processor, we will start to see more games being developed for the Mac. But, honestly, don't most people get their gaming fix by playing with video game consoles (such as NES, PS, Wii, or XBox), rather than playing games on their computers?



* Software.

There's a lot more software for the Macintosh now, than before Mac OS X arrived. Much of the Mac's new software is simply Unix ports. There is also a large open source and public domain/shareware development community that has been supporting the Mac OS.



http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/



You can run Unix X-windows on your Macintosh now too. Apple has been designated as the largest distributor of Unix in the world. If you have one of the new Intel-based Macs you can now run Windows programs natively using a program called Boot Camp and/or Parallel. There is also a Java Virtual Machine for the Mac too.



There's still a ton of programs made specifically for the Mac. Most of these are programmed in machine language, so they're lightening fast. Apple watches over their developers closely, to make sure everything runs like it's supposed to; that it runs the Macintosh way. There's also a lot of Windows ports too. I use Microsoft Office on my Mac at work all the time. Although the Macintosh versions of Windows software are way behind in features than their Windows brethren, the Macintosh programs seem to run better, faster and are not as susceptible to problems as the Windows ports. Go figure!



Where the Macintosh really shines is in the creative software area. I'm a printer, so I know that the Macintosh pioneered desktop publishing. I think that most structured drawing, paint/graphics, and music programs got their start here too. Video and film editing and production is now very big on the Mac. Many people complain about how expensive some of these programs are, but frankly, professional programs are always more expensive than the cheaper consumer-level programs that are out there. Stuff like iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie, iDVD, etc. come free with your Macintosh, while other programs are quite affordable.



http://www.versiontracker.com/macosx



* Less problems

The Macintosh simply works. There really isn't very many problems using a Mac compared to a Windows PC. Check out the computer questions here on Yahoo! Answers. There are a lot of Windows, "Why can't I get this to work?" questions here. Even though there are a lot of Mac users here, there doesn't seem to be very many Mac questions. The Mac simply works. Naturally, there are a few problems with any kind of computer hardware, but these are few and far between on a Mac.



* Hardware Power -vrs- Expense



Right, the Macintosh is a little more proprietary and you really need to buy hardware that tells you that it's Macintosh compatible. You can't just buy some cheap hardware, piece it together, and make a Mac, like you can with some PCs. But, then, you don't have Plug-and-Pray either. Again, the Mac simply works.



We also hear from Windows users that Windows PCs are cheaper than Macs. True, you can buy hardware with the barest of graphics cards, hard drives, and other components, or you can buy the best and end up spending the same amount as a Mac. It's your choice, but that's why you see Macs holding up and being used a lot longer than these Window PCs.



Oh, and since we're talking about hardware, yes, you can get yourself a USB multiple-buttoned mouse, plug it into your Mac, and use it just fine, thank you. Don't worry about it.



* Mac OS X

It's a very simple, basic, easy-to-use OS. It's highly graphic, so your kids or your grandmother could learn to use it, and it's also got a terminal, so the geekiest guy can enjoy using it to it's fullest extent. Windows users will recognize many of the same features that they use on their OS, but there are a few things that are strictly Macintosh.



http://www.apple.com/support/switch101/

http://www.apple.com/support/mac101/

http://switchtoamac.com/guides/



I have loved it because it's always responsive. You throw in a CD and the icon for it pops up on the desktop along with a dialog box asking if you want a specific program to use with it. There's no need to search for drives. If it's a music CD, iTunes launches to play it. If you plug in your digital camera iPhoto launches to import the pictures. If you're looking for a file buried deep inside your Mac's file structure, you can use Spotlight and it might find the file before you're done typing the first three letters of the name.



Again, I'm sorry that this is so long, but I get tired of the misinformation that the Windows guys are spreading about the Macintosh, and I wanted to be sure to respond to all of their rants with the facts. Go into your local Macintosh dealer and play with the Macintosh yourself, and see what you think. Best of luck with your final decision. Take care.



--Rick


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...